Peer Review Policy
Smart Internet of Things (SIOT) uses double-anonymous (double-blind) peer review. The process is designed to assess scholarly merit fairly while protecting the independence, confidentiality, and dignity of authors, reviewers, and editors.
Editorial Assessment
Every submission first undergoes an editorial assessment for scope, originality, completeness, ethical concerns, methodological suitability, and the clarity of its contribution. A manuscript may be declined before external review when it falls outside the journal’s scope, is materially incomplete, does not offer a sufficiently developed contribution, or raises unresolved research-integrity concerns.
Reviewer Selection and Evaluation
Original research articles, methodological contributions, and review or survey articles undergo double-anonymous peer review and may be accepted only after substantive reports from at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise. Additional reviews may be sought when needed. Initial editorial rejection without external review is distinct from acceptance and does not waive this requirement. Reviewers are asked to assess, as appropriate:
- the originality, significance, and clarity of the contribution;
- the soundness of the theory, methods, analysis, or computational design;
- the adequacy of evidence, baselines, validation, and robustness analysis;
- the quality and balance of the references;
- the transparency of assumptions, limitations, and reporting; and
- ethical and integrity-related aspects of the work.
Reviewer reports should be constructive, evidence-based, and sufficiently detailed to help the editor and authors understand the reasoning behind the recommendation. Reviewers should not contact authors directly or share a manuscript with another person without the editor’s permission.
Suggested references must have a clear scholarly purpose. Reviewers and editors must not use the review process to obtain irrelevant citations for themselves, SIOT, or another journal, or make acceptance conditional on reciprocal citation arrangements. Authors may explain why a suggested reference is not relevant and may report coercive requests through the journal’s complaints procedure.
Confidentiality and Anonymity
Manuscripts, review reports, editorial correspondence, and unpublished findings are confidential. Reviewers and editorial staff must not disclose, copy, circulate, use, or publicly discuss material obtained through the review process. Authors should remove identifying information from files prepared for anonymous review and should not attempt to identify reviewers. Anonymity does not prevent the journal from taking appropriate action when research-integrity concerns or a formal investigation require disclosure.
Editorial Decisions and Revisions
Editors consider the reviewers’ assessments but retain responsibility for the editorial decision. Possible outcomes include decline without external review, reject, major or minor revision, and accept. A decision is not determined by a single report; when reports conflict or further expertise is needed, the editor may seek an additional review or conduct further editorial assessment.
Authors invited to revise should respond point by point, identify substantive changes clearly, and explain any disagreement with a reviewer’s suggestion in a professional and evidence-based manner. Revision does not guarantee acceptance, and the revised manuscript may be returned to reviewers.
Conflicts of Interest and Recusal
Reviewers and editors must disclose and manage personal, professional, financial, institutional, or other interests that could affect impartial judgment. A reviewer should decline an invitation when a conflict cannot be managed fairly. An editor must recuse themselves from a manuscript involving a significant conflict and ensure that the manuscript is handled independently.
Submissions authored or coauthored by an editor, board member, or publisher employee are subject to the same standards and required external reviews as other submissions. An independent, unconflicted editor handles the manuscript; the author-editor has no role in selecting reviewers, evaluating reports, or deciding the outcome. If both Editors-in-Chief are conflicted, an appropriately qualified, independent senior editor is assigned. Any resulting publication identifies the independent handling and the conflicted editor’s non-involvement.
Research Integrity and Post-Publication Action
Suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or manipulated data, authorship disputes, peer-review manipulation, and other integrity concerns are assessed through a documented process consistent with the journal’s publication-ethics policy and relevant COPE guidance. Where necessary, SIOT may publish a correction, editor’s note, expression of concern, or retraction notice. Such notices remain linked to the version of record so that the scholarly record is clear and traceable.
Use of AI in Peer Review
Reviewers must not upload, paste, or otherwise enter confidential manuscript or peer review material into AI tools. This includes unpublished manuscripts and extracts, figures, data, review reports and drafts, and editorial correspondence. The journal may expressly permit AI assistance only for limited language or structural editing of non-confidential text. Reviewers must disclose any such use to the editor, verify the output, and take full responsibility for the report. AI must not substitute for the reviewer’s independent scholarly judgment or generate a recommendation or decision.
Any transfer of confidential review material to an external system for purposes other than AI use requires the journal’s explicit permission.
SIOT takes relevant publication-ethics guidance, including COPE resources, into account when developing and applying its review procedures. For further information, consult the COPE publication-ethics resources.